I am old enough to remember the reports in the old Battle magazine, and then in Military Modelling by Tony Bath about his Hyborian campaign. I did not manage to read them all (my branch of WH Smith’s did not take Battle, I think), but for years they were a yardstick of my wargame campaigns, so much more so when I got myself a copy of Setting Up a Wargames Campaign. I was not alone; as I recall in Lone Warrior at the time (late 1970s / early 1980s), more or less everyone seemed to be setting up an island, continent, or world of their own.
It was therefore a bit interesting when the History of Wargaming Project published
Forging the First Fantasy Wargame: A Companion to Tony Bath’s Hyborian Campaign (2026), edited by John Curry.
I have now, more or less, read the volume, and so I thought I would share a few thoughts about it. I do suspect that my loyal reader is of a similar age and, probably, remembers the reports of the campaign, possibly as I do. But we have to be careful; there was no golden age of wargaming.
Firstly, let me get my gripes out of the way. I have one main one, which is that the bulk of the material is scanned in and optically character recognised (OCR). This is fine, except that unfortunately the recognised text is, in some places, littered with typos and words which make no sense in context. I know that old texts can be hard to scan in and are not as bold as modern printed pages would be, but errors are errors. This is also true of one or two other History of Wargaming Project texts I own, and is a shame because half an hour or so with a spellchecker and simple grammar corrector would have made the text a lot less irritating to read. Perhaps I am showing my age, but I wonder if Dr Curry, as an academic, would accept a text so error-littered from one of his students.
Anyway, as you would expect, and which pleased me, the bulk of the book is formed from the articles Bath wrote for the magazines. They are an interesting read, showing how the campaign evolved from a fairly straightforward two-player affair between Bath and Featherstone, to a much more complex, in part character-led, affair. Bath keeps the narrative flowing, and the book reproduces the maps and other diagrams, which do help. However, not everything is mapped, and not every character has their background explained. I suppose that it helps with the feeling that the campaign has further depths than are explained.
Certainly, reading the articles with the knowledge given by Setting Up… leads me to conclude that Bath intervened much more frequently and decisively than I would in the campaign. He, basically, at times, made things happen, rather than let circumstances and characters make their own way. Each to their own, I suppose. I often wondered how he managed to stay on top of such a complex world mapped and modelled in such depth, and I am starting to conclude that, quite possibly, he did not, except when he wanted to.
Which leads me back, I suppose, to the question of the purpose of a wargame campaign in the first place. In my view, the aim is that it should generate wargames, and that is how my own 1600 Something campaign works. Other people’s ideas on that may vary, of course, and this is where the book starts to be suggestive, but rather under-developed.
The point in question is the development of role-playing games. Dungeons and Dragons was first produced in 1974, as we know, and preceding it was a rule set called Chainmail, based on medieval warfare. In the introduction to the book, Curry shows that Gary Gygax was influenced by the English wargame rules of the time, particularly by Featherstone and Bath. But D&D is a role-playing game, not a strict tabletop wargame as those rules outlined.
On the other hand, Hyboria evolved into a campaign where the players (when it became a multi-player by mail game) had roles as leaders or sub-leaders of states, provinces (etc.) and, it would seem, had characters to go along with them. So, I suppose, if a real-life player took on a role of someone who was disloyal, shifty, and with an eye to the ladies, within the game they had to play that role, as well as the leadership one. This is not, in my experience, how role-playing games work, particularly. Mostly, the character is made by the player, guided by the characteristics and background of the player-character.
That is not to say that Bath ‘got it wrong’ or anything; it is just that I am not sure that his style of role-playing took off particularly. I think most players would find it restrictive and rather unnecessary, although I do recall it could materialise in those dreadful ‘team-building’ exercises that so bedevilled office awaydays in the 1990s and beyond.
I said the introduction was a bit underdeveloped, and I mean that the idea of parallel development could have been, I think, pushed a bit further. From a common basis in the various rule sets, I can see how Gygax could create something based around personal combat. Many of the early wargame rules were based around figures and their individual arms and abilities. Wargame rules that treated units as units came a little bit later, I think, although the kernel could be found in morale rules and the like.
In summary, gripes about typographical errors aside, I did enjoy the book, although the listings of people and the various territories did get a bit wearing. It was a bit of a hike down memory lane, and I did recognise some of the articles, maps, and diagrams from the originals. It certainly provides food for thought about what a wargame campaign is for, and how much a player or umpire might manipulate it to get what they want from it. And in that, I suppose, campaigns parallel role-playing games, which are best defined, really, as collaborative world-building games, where player decisions make the context, the world, and the activities.
There is more to say about this, I am sure, but I’ve gone on long enough, and will have to ponder further in order to make any further progress (one way or another). I suppose the last thing is to say that both Hyboria and RPGs encourage campaigns, which might be worth a thought.





